new_york_tribune_boundaries_of_old_russian_poland_13july_1919.pdf
(
1231 KB
)
Pobierz
156473768 UNPDF
The
Sore
Spots
of
Middle
Europe
Fourteen
Districts
in
Which
Lie
¦*¦
-"-*-'.
-«-«7-LÍ7
m
¡What
Remains
To
Be
Done
at
the
The
No
Man's
Lands
of
the
Balkans
The
Germs
of
Future
Hostilities
Peace
Conference
Is
Far
More
There
Is
Possibility
of
an
Alliance
|
of
Germany,
Russia
and
Italy
Than
What
Has
Already
Been
Done.Many
Danger
Spots
By
Frank
II.
Simonds
in
the
Complex
Balkan
Prob¬
lem That Awaits
Solution
IT
IS,
perhaps,
a
mere
truism
to
remark that what
remains
to
he
done
at
the Paris
Conference
is
far
more
considerable
alike in bulk
and
in
importance
than
what
has
been
accomplished
in
th«
treaty
with
Germany. Still,
there
may
be
a
cer-i
tain
surprise
in
pointing
out
that the
treaty
recently signed
disposes
of
less
than
10 per cent
of
the
territory
which
must
be
apportioned
before
the
work
of
making
peace
is
ever,
while
the
population
awaiting
alio-
cation
is
something
like
seventy
millions,
as
compared
with
the
less
than
seventy
millions
divided
in the
Versailles
settlement.
The
Allies,
who
have
conquered
Germany
and
imposed
their
peace
terms upon
her,
have
now
to
sepa¬
rate
Austria-Hungary
into its
com¬
ponent
racial
parts,
deal with
the
Kusso-Polish
problem,
the
Russo-
Rumanian
question,
bring
about
a
settlement
so
far
as
England
is
con¬
cerned,
dispose
of
the
tangled
prob¬
lem
of
Constantinople
and the
6hores
of
the
Straits
and
impose
peace
terms
upon
Bulgaria.
Must
Reconcile
Racial
Disputes
Not less
difficult
is
the task of
reconciling
the
disputes
between the
separate
races
on
which the several
provinces
of
Austria
are
to
be
be¬
stowed,
accommodating
the
acute
quarrel
between the southern Slavs
and
the
Italians,
and
thus
bringing
a
little order
and
calm
out
of
that
great
central
chaos
which
now ex¬
tends
from
the Baltic
to
the
Mgean
and
from
the
Adriatic
to
the Black
Sea.
Until
these
things
are accom¬
plished
thc-Ve
can
be
no
peace
in
Eu¬
rope,
rind in the
accomplishment
of
eyen
a
temporary
arrangement
there
may
be
sown
the
seeds of
many
future
wars.
To
begin
at
the
beginning,
there
js
the Russian
problem.
It
may
be
{divided
into
two
equally important
Varis;
there
is
the
question
of Rus¬
sia
itself and the
question
of the
various
races on
the
fringe
of
the
raised;
if
Russia
were
conquered
after
a
war
waged
against
Britain,
France
and
Italy,
then
terms
like
those
imposed
upon
Germany
would
be.
possible.
But
neither the
one nor
the
other
condition is
fulfilled.
Rus¬
sia
was
long
an
ally,
and
a
useful
ally;
she
finally
collapsed
and
made
a
separate
peace;
but does this
jus¬
tify
her
recent
allies
in
treating
her
as
an
enemy
and
dividing
her
terri¬
1,500,000
and there
is
not
any
race
in the
many
who
inhabit
it
which
has
a
clear
majority.
The
Ruma¬
nians outnumber
the
German?,
Serbs and
Magyars,
who
are
all
thejj»
in
considerable
numbers,
biff
the Germans and the
Magyars
com¬
bined would
outnumber
the
Ruma¬
nians.
Moreover,
the
southwestern
districts
are
Serb,
the
northwest¬
ern
Magyar,
but
to
give
these dis¬
tricts
to
the
Serbs and the
Magyars
would be
to
deprive
the
Rumanians
living
in the
uplands
of
their
natural and
necessary
means
of
communication
to
the Theiss
and
Danube
rivers,
by
which*
they
ex¬
port
their
produce.
Rumania
Claims
All of the Banat
Now
the
Rumanians claim all
the
Banat
and
have
to
support
their
claim
a
separate,
secret
treaty
with
the Western allies.
It
was a
part
of
the
reward
promised
them for
entering
the
war.
But
when
they
entered
they
were
betrayed,
de¬
feated
and
compelled
to
make
a
separate
peace.
Does
this invali¬
date
the.
pledge given by
the
Western allies? At
least
the
Ru¬
manians
deny
it. But the
Serbs
assert
this
to
be the
caseT
point
to
the fact that
the
population
of
the
districts
claimed
is
Serb,
and would
vote
for
union
with the
new
Jugo¬
slav
state,
and
argue
that
Mr.
Wil¬
son
does
not
recognize
secret
trea¬
ties
anyway.
Then
the
Magyar.;
claim the
district about
Szegedin,
which is
Hungarian,
on
the
same
ground
of self-determination. As
for the
Germans,
close
to
half
a
million in
number,
they
seem
re
signed
to
losing
in
any
case.
If the
Western Allies
recognize
Serbian claims and fail
to
accepl
Rumanian
claims in
Bessarabia,
Ru
mania
will
make
an
alliance witr
Italy,
which has
a
dispute
with ttu
Jugo-Slavs
on
her hands. More
over,
Bulgaria,
despite
her
quarre
with
Rumania
over
the
Dobrudja
might
easily
be
placated by
a
prom
ise
of
the
Macedonian
territory
she has
waged
three
wars
to
ac¬
quire,
and then
we
should have
;
new
Balkan
problem
on
our
hand:
at
once.
To
suppose
that the
West
ern
powers
would
go
to
war
agaii
to
save
Serbia
is
to
suppose
the
impossible,
but
this is
exactly
whi:
would be
necessary
if
the
league
oi
nations
were
to
be
preserved
at all
Problem
to
Atone
For
Wrongs
Done
But.
if
the Serbs
are
denied their
part
of
the
Banat,
if this
injury
is
added
to
the
wrong,
the
palpable
wrong,
already
done
in
the hinter
lands of
Trieste,
where half
a
mil¬
lion
Slavs have
been
turned
over
tc
Italy,
and
to
the
probable
wrong
tc
be
done,
under the
terms
of the
Anglo-French-Italian
secret
treatj
affecting Dalmatia,
then
we
shal
have
exactly
the
same
menace
tc
world
peace
that Serbia
constitutec
from the
Congress
of Vienna dowr
to
the
assassination
at
Serajevo
when the
whole
world
was
em
broiled.
Moreover,
Italy
and Ruma
nia,
two
Latin states, with
strong
sympathies
and
a common
enemy
might
easily
find
a
basis
of
agree
ment
with
Germany,
looking
for
al
lies and
necessarily
prepared
U
trade
upon
the
differences
and
profi
Slavia
and
suppress
Greece.
Both the
latter
frankly
ask
only
for
what
they
are
entitled
to
have
according
to
the
famous
Fourteen
Points.
Italy
and
Rumania,
on
the
other
hand,
can
point
to
the
pledges
given
by
their
allies in
secret
treaties;
moreover,
in the
matter
of
Bessarabia,
Rumania's
claim is in¬
disputable.
There
remains
the
dispute
be¬
tween
the
Italians
and
the
Jugo¬
tories,
cutting
her off
from
the
Bal¬
tic;
in
effect,
ratifying
the.
terms
of
tlio
treaty
which
her
enemy
Ger¬
many
imposed
upon
her,
swovd in
hand>
at
Brest-Li
to\»fil<?
Unfortunately,
the
progress
of
events at
Paris
already
has
resulted
in
the
permanent
alienation
of
Italy;
slavs
over
Fiume
and
Dalmatia,
the
merits of
which
are so
well
known
to
my
readers
that
I shall
not
re¬
peat former
analyses
here.
But
it
is
an
element
in
the
larger
culcula-
|
tion.
Italy
is
practically
outside the
j
western
alliance
now;
she feels her-
nothing
is
more
certain
than
that,
once
the
chance
comes,
Italy
will
re¬
turn
to
her
old
German
alliance.
To
insure that
Russia,
when she
does
become
a
great
power
again,
as
she
almost
certainly
must,
because of
the
fashion
in which
her old allies
have
treated
her,
shall
also
turn to
the
Germans
is
to
provide
for
a
new
war,
with
every
chance in favor of
a
victory
by
the
new
alliance.
The
real
difficulty
which
con¬
fronts the
men
who have to
carry
on
the work
of
peacemaking
is
the
puzzle
about Russia.
We
have
rec¬
ognized
the
independence
of Fin¬
land,
but
Kolchak
flatly
refuses
to
recognize
it
on
his
part.
We have
recognized
the claim
of Polaml
to
freedom,
which
Kolchak
also
con¬
cedes,
but what is
to
bo
Poland's
eastern
limit? The
boundaries
of
the old
Russian
Poland?
But
the
Polish armies
are
in
Wilna,
Minsk
and
Kove!,
fighting
Bolshevist forces.
Certainly
if Kolchak will
not
recog¬
nize the
independence
of
Finland
he will
not consent to
the
separa¬
tion
of
Lithuania,
White Russia
and
Volhynia
from
the
old
Muscovite
state.
Nor
is
the
dispute
merely
be¬
tween
the Pole
and
the
Russian
here.
Qn
the
contrary,
the Poles
desire
to
restore
the
old confedera¬
tion
between
Lithuania
and
Poland,
while the
Lithuanians
desire
uncon¬
ditional
independence,
and
even
if
this
were
granted
there is
still
to
be
settled
the
age-long
difference
be¬
tween
two
peoples
as
to
their boun¬
daries. If the
Paris conference
gives
Poland
White Russia
and
Lithuania,
it alienates
the Russians
and the
Lithuanians;
if it does
not,
it
alienates
the
Poles.
If it
returns
the Lithuanians
to
Russia,
it
alien¬
ates
both these
people
and the Poles
and does violence
to
the
right
of
self-determination of
peoples.
Then there is the
problem
of
Riga,
of
Libau,
of the
provinces
of the
Courland,
Esthonia and
Livonia,
with
a
certain
minority
of
German
inhabitants
and
a
strong
separatist
sentiment. To
take these
away
from Russia would be
to
undo the
work of Peter the
Great
and
le'avn
Russia without
access
to
the
Baltic.
New
War
Against
Russia Possible
But
precisely
these
people
are
asking,
with
Allied
help,
a
gallant
fight
against
the Bolshevist Rus¬
sians;
shall
they
be rewarded
by
betrayal
to
the Russians? If
they
are,
they
will
unquestionably
fight
with German
aid.German
troops
are
still
there.against
Russia
until
such
time
as
Russia
and
Germany
come
to terms
over
the
whole
set
of
questions
that
concern
them.
(
It
is,
then,
no
simple
tangle,
this
problem
of the
Baltic and Polish
hinter¬
lands.
In the
solving
of
it,
the
main
ques
tion
necessarily
will be the self-in¬
terest
of the Western
powers.
Ii
would be
idle
to
expect
Great Brit
ain
and
France
to
alienate Russia
by
ceding
her
territories
to
Polana
and
one
or
more
independent
Baltic
states,
thus
insuring
a
speedy
com¬
bination
of
Russia and
Germany
tc
undo this
work.
The
fact
'
that
every
Europear
recognizes
and
most
Americans dis
regard
is
that
the
German
victory
over
Rus'sia
destroyed
the
balance
of
power
in
Europe,
which
was
re
stored
only
when
we
sent
great
armies
to the
Continent.
Thest
armies
have
mostly departed;
theii
return
under
any
cirmustances i;
at least
problematical
;
therefore,
i<
is
of
Utmost
importance
to the West
em
powers,
if
they
are
to
exist,
t(
prevent
an
alliance
between Russir
and Germany,
which would
be
al
most
irresistible.
This
can
b<
avoided
only,
if
at
all,
by
so
framinf
the
terms
of
peace
as
not
to dis
xatisfy
the
Russia
of
to-morrow
which,
one
must
assume,
will b<
strong
and
mindful
of its histori«
greatness.
That
is
w>y
the whole Russiar
¡
self
badly
treated;
she
resents
Pres-
ident
Wilson's
criticism;
she
feels,
not
unjustly,
that her
European
al-
lies
have
sided
with the
President
rather
than with
her.
If
Germany
is
sullenly revengeful, Italy
is
open-
iy
dissatisfied;
therefore
no
solution
of
the
Adriatic
problem
that she
would
even
consider
would
do
jus-
tice
to'
Slav
rights
and
no
solution
which
ignores
Slav
rights
can
per-
manently
satisfy
the
great
nation of
southern
Slavs, including
the
best
fighting
race
in
Europe,
which is
destined
to
rise
on
the
eastern
shores
of
the
Adriatic.
Nor
can
we*
expect
the
Greeks
ever
to
accept
definitely
the
loss of
northern
Epi¬
rus
or
the
islands
of
the
.'-gean,
which
have been
Hellenic in
history
The black
areas
are
disputed
territories
the
disposition of
which
must
still
he
decided
by
the
Peace
_
since
the
very
beginning
of
history.
These
circumstances explain
Eu¬
ropean
despair
in
the
presence
of
the
Conference
problems
of
peacemaking.
'But,"
my
American
friends
argue,
'the
league
of
nations
will
arrange
everything.''
But
how
can
the
league
of
nations
reconcile
the Serbs
to
the
loss of
hundreds
of
thousands
of
Slavs
to
Italy,
the
Greeks
to
the
sur-
problem
has continued
to
paralyze
the
Paris
conference.
A
mistake,
tRe
"backing
of
the
wrong
horse,"
would
be
fatal.
Lloyd
George
and
Wilson
were
willing
to
flirt with Lé¬
nine,
some
months
ago,
because
neither
was
directly exposed
to
Rus¬
sian invasion
if
the
reactionary
fac¬
tion
regained control,
but
France is;
has been invaded
by
Russians
at
least
twice
in
a
little
more
than
a
century,
and
France
was
always
op^
posed
to
that
man.uvre
which
ended
ingloriously
in
the
Prinkipo
fiasco.
We
have,
as
a
result
of
our,
peace¬
making
so
far,
alienated
Italy
and
created
a
sullen,
resentful,'revenge¬
ful
Germany.
Both
circumstances
were
approximately
inevitable:
at
least there
was
no
escape
from
the
German
detail.
To
add
to
these
a
Russia,
destined
to
be
again
the
greatest
power
on
the
Continent,
would be
for
France
and
Great
Britain,
with
her
Indian
Empire
and
her
Mesopotamian
colony,
to
com¬
mit
suicide*
Poland
Has
Many
Troubles
in
Store
Therefore,
it is
not
going
to
be
easy
or
rapid
work,
this
settling
the
eastern
frontiers
of
Poland
and
Ru¬
mania
and
the
future
status
of the
Baltic
provinces.
I
should
guess
that in
the end Finland
would
be
confirmed in
her
independence,
Po¬
land
in
the
possession
of
not much
more
than the
old
area
of
Russian
Poland,
including
Cholm,
while Ru¬
manian
possession
of
Bessarabia,
which
exists,
might
be
tolerated but
would
hardly
be
sanctioned. That
is,
it
might
be left for
Rumania
to
settle the
dispute directly
with
Rus¬
sia, without,
however, receiving
in
advance
any
guarantee
from
the
Western
powers,
although
no one
disputes
the fact that the
great
ma¬
jority
of the
population
are
Ru¬
manian
by
race.
Even
this
summary
retreat
does
not,
however, dispose
of all the
ques¬
tions
affecting
Poland.
To-day
Pol¬
ish
armies
are
fighting
the
Ukraini¬
ans
in Eastern
Galicia,
and
there
is
an
historic
dispute
between
these
peoples
for
the
possession
of East¬
ern
Galicia,
with
Lemberg,
the
cap¬
ital,
which
is
itself
a
Polish
city,
sur¬
rounded
by
a
Ruther.ian
speaking
country.
Had
Russia
stayed
in
the
war
she
would
have annexed
all
of
Galicia
with
the
consent
of
the
Western
powers,
but
what
now?
First of
all,
will the
Ukraine
en¬
dure
as
a
separate
state
or
will it
revert
to
Russia? Should
the West-
ern
powers
follow
the
German
ex-
ample
and
recognize
the
independ¬
ence
of the
Ukraine
or
not?
To
recognize
would be
to
alienate the
Northern Russians
and
the
Poles;
not
to
recognize might
be to
guess
wrong,
for
the
Ukrainians
might
gain
liberty.
But
to
bestow
Eastern
Galicia
upon
the
Poles
would alien¬
ate
both
the
Russians and the
Ukrainians
and
lead
to
serious
con¬
sequences:
Meantime
the
Poles
hold
all
of
it,
as'^a
result
of
their
victories,
and
mean
to
hang
on.
Then there is
the
dispute
between
the
Poles
and
the Czecho-Slovaks
over
Teschen,
a
tiny'territory,
im¬
mensely
rich
in
minerals,
lying
be¬
tween
Polish and Czech
peoples
at
the
headwaters
of the
Oder and the
Vistula.
A
majority
of
the
popula
tion
is
Polish,
but
the
Czechs
have
an
economic
necessity
tö
possess
the
land,
at
least
they
allege
such
a
necessity,
and
the Paris
conference
once
conceded
it to
them. Then
it
repented.
Two Slav
Peoples
ticklish
puzzle,
which
we
may
call
the
Rumanian
question.
The
new
Rumania
is
shaped something
like
a
square,
and
on
each of
its four
sides it has
a
near-war
in
progress.
On
the
east
it
disputes
with the
Ukrainians
and thus with
the Rus-
sians
the
territory
once
comprising
the
Russian
province
of Bessarabia.
On the
north it is
at
odds
with
Husigary
over
a
vast
area
of
Ru-
manian
speaking
lands,
which
it
has taken in
recent
months. On tho
sj^uth
there
is
the
old
quarrel
with
I
render
of
nearly
half
a
million Hel-
lenes
to
Italy
and
Italy's
new
ward,
With
Daggers
Drawn
Now the
question
is
open
again,
with
the
two
Slav
peoples
at
dag¬
gers
drawn.
To
give
it
to
one
would
be
to
alienate
the
other,
to
estab
lish
a
separate
state
under the
guar¬
antee of
the
league
of
nations would
be
to
alienate
both and
erect
an
in¬
defensible
state,
one
more
indefen¬
sible
state
in
Europe,
without
any
desire for
independence
and
with
absolutely
no
means
of
defending
its
unsought
independence
or
re¬
ceiving
aid
from
the nations
which
»would
thus
create
it.
To
sum
up,
then,
the
Allies,
with
cur
assistance,
must
give
Poland
an
eastern
frontier,
since
they
have
recognized
its
right
to
exist. To
do
this
they
must
assign
Russian
territory
to
Poland,
yet
it is
of
utmost
importance
that
they
do
not
alienate
Russian
national senti¬
ment,
drive
a
restored
Russia
into
German
arms.
*
The
same
problem
must
be
faced
in
dealing
with
Finland,
the Baltic
provinces,
Lithuania,
while
there
also is
the
grave
danger
incident
tc
alienating
the
Poles,
the Lithua
nians,
the
peoples
of the
Baltic
provinces
and
the
Czecho-Slovaks
as
each
or
all
feel
their
own
rights
under
the
Fourteen
Points,
abridgec
by
the necessities of the
Greai
Powers.
There
remains
an
almost
equalh
Albania?
And how
can
the
league
of
nations
reconcile
Italy
to
permit¬
ting
a
new
Slav
state
to
rise
across
the
Adriatic
or
to
consent¬
ing
to
the
creation
of
a
Greek
state
which will
doom
all
her
hopes
in
the
Kgean
and
on
the
west
coast
of
Asia
Minor,
at
the
precise
moment
when
Britain
and
France,
by
the
new
peace,
are
realizing
their
aspi-
rations,
both
in
Syria
and
Mesopo-
tamia in
Asia
and in
Egypt
and
Morocco in
Africa?
Americans
See But
A
Single
Solution
Then,
again,
the
American
point
of
view,
influenced
by
the
Fourteen
fild
Russian
state,
which
are
seeking
Bulgaria
over
all
of
the
Dobrudja
in
general
and
the Southern Do-
brudja
in
particular.
On
the
west
there
is
a
new
quarrel
with
the
Serbs
over
the
western
fringe
of
the Banat.
For
the Western
powers
to
rec¬
ognize
-Rumanian
claims
to
Bessa¬
rabia would be
to
alienate Russian
opinion, precisely
as
in
the
north.
But
to
fail
to
recognize
Rumanian
claims would be
to
deny
the Four¬
teen
Points,
since the
people
are
Rumanian
and
have
already
self-
determined
themselves
to
be
such,
and,
even
more
serious,
to
alienate
th.e
Rumanian
nation,
which
is
des¬
tined
to
be
one
of
the
great
powers
of the
future in
Europe, larger
in
area
than the mainland
of
Italy,
and
capable
of
sustaining
at
least
as
large
a
population.
If
Rumania
finds
her
claims
denied,
she
unques¬
tionably
will
renounce
her associa¬
tion
with the
Western
powers;
so
much she
has
already
threatened
to
do.
Then there is
the
dispute
with
the
Serbs
over
the Banat.
Now the
Banat exists
to
confute the
Four¬
teen
Points. It
has
a
population
of
Ing
permanent separation
from
Rus-
¡ia,
precisely
as
the
Danes,
the
Poles
and the
people
of
Alsace-Lor¬
raine
sougjit
liberation from the
German
yoke.
Policy
on
Russia
»
Is
Complex
Problem
As
to
Russia
herself,
what
policy
will
the
Allies
adopt?
They
can¬
not
recognize
Lénine and the
Reds,
both
because the
things
these
people
represent
are
abhorrent
to
all
of
the
ideas
of western
civilization
and be¬
cause,
unless
recognized
by
the
out¬
side
world,
they
will
shortly collapse
of
their
own
weight.
But
if
there is
to
be
peace
in
Eu¬
rope
there
must
be
peace
in
Russia,
and
to
obtain
peace
in Russia it
is
eninntial
that
the western
powers
»hould find
some
substitute
for
the
anarchy
and
suicide
of the Lénine
régime. Apparently
the Allies
now
are
placing
their
hopes
upon
Kol-
chak,
but this
decision is
arousing
protest in Britain
and
France,
where Kolchak
is
seen as a
reaction¬
ary, and in neither
country
is there
any
desire
to restore
in
Russia
the
tyranny
of the
old,
stupid
and
cor¬
rupt
régime,
which
has
gone.
Granted
that
Kolchak
can
over¬
throw
Lénine
and
Trotzky,
however,
this
only
raises
new
problems.
He
Will
come
to Moscow and
Petrograd
a«
the
champion
of
a
restored
Rus-
rta,
of
a
reunited
Russia,
and
is
it
conceivable that
he
will
consent,
that
Points,
conceives
that there
is
only
one
just
solution,
and
that such
a
solution,
if
reached,
will
close the
debate.
Unhappily,
there
are
fre¬
quently
at
least
'two
solutions
con-
forming
to
justice
as
laid
down
by
the
Fourteen
Points,
and
in
some
cases,
as
in
the
Banat,
a
situation
where the
Fourteen Points
have
no
application,
since
self-determination
is
impossible
as
a
whole,
and,
if
the
vote
of
the
people
be had
in
the vari¬
ous
districts,
commercial
ruin
will
result.
Finally
there
is
the
European
point
of
view,
which
no
American-
k
reckons
with,
the
point
of
view
of
the
French
and
British,
who
have
to
face the
eventuality
of
a
restored
Russia,
the
certainty
of
a
vengeful
by
the
mistakes of the Paris
Peaci
Conference.
There is
also
a
Greek
complicatioi
to
be reckoned with.
The
Greek:
and Serbs have
a
treaty
of
allianci
against
the
Bulgarians
and Greeci
claims
the
old
.Egean
coast
of Bui
garia
in
western
Thraee. In addi
tion, Greece
has
a
quarrel
with
thi
Italians
affecting
northern
Epirus
the
Dodecanesus
Islands,
witl
Rhodes
and the
western
shore
o
Asia
Minor,
including
Smyrna
Northern
Epirus
is
Greek
by right
but
Italy
has
prevented
Greece fron
occupying
it,
and
now,
as
th
mandatory
of
Albania, occupies
i
herself. The
Dodecanesus
an
Rhodes
are
Greek
speaking,
bu
Italy has
held
them since her Tr:
politan
War.
Finally,
the
wester
powers
promised
Smyrna
to
Italj
but have
recently
permitted
Greec
to
occupy
it.
Thus
the
Balkans
are
beginnin;
to
divide
again,
with
Greece
an<
Jugo-Slavia
in
ore
camp
and
Ital;
Will
America
Adopt
the
Armenians?
Germany
and the
growing
fact of
a
thoroughly
dissatisfied
Italy,
whose
dissatisfaction
grows out
of the
re-
!
jection
of
claims she holds
%just,
which
were
agreed
to
by
her
allies,
but
rejected
by
President
Wilson,
in
j
accordance
with
his
views of
justice,
views
which,
in the
abstract
at
least,
cannot
be
disputed.
If
Germany,
Russia
and
Italy
find
a
common
basis for
cooperation
in
upsetting
the
present
settlement
in
Europe,
where
is
the
force
coming
/
.r-
^
/
.'--
Greeks
charge
the Italians with
secret¬
ly
pricking
on
the Turks
to
attack
the
Greeks.
Constantinople
is
the
key
to
the Turkish
problem,
and
the
American
answer on
the
Constantinople
mandatp
is
matter
of
pressing importance.
American
officials
here
formerly
were
impressed
by
the
argument
that
the
Sultan'g
removal from
Constantinople
would
deeply
offend
the Mussulman
populations
everywhere.
They
now
confess
that
fuller
knowledge destroys
this
case.
The
experts
and
scholars
who have been
consulted declare that
Constantinople
never
has
been
consid¬
ered
a
sacred
place
by
the
Mussulmans,
still less the sacred
city
of
Islam,
for
it
always
has
retained
New
York
Tribune
Special
Cable
Service
(Copyright,
1919.
New
York Tribuno
Inc.)
PARIS,
July
12.-Official
circles
ad-
mit that the
sole
reason
fbr
post¬
poning
the
Turkish
problem
is
the
necessity
of
knowing
whether America
will
accept
a
mundate
for
Armenia,
Con¬
stantinople
and Asia Minor. It is
un¬
derstood
that before
hjs
departure
President Wilson told Clemenceau and
Lloyd
George
that
he
thought
the Ar¬
menian
mandate
was
feasible,
but
it
was
utterly impossible
to
offer
an
opinion
in
regard
to
Constantinople
and Asia
Minor.
Constantinople
Is
etanism,
always
have refused
to
recognize
the
religious
supremacy
of
the
Sultan,
whi'e
Mussulman
authori¬
ties
by
their
official acts
and docu¬
ments
avow
that
Constantinople
has
preserved
its Christian
and
Hellenic
character.
When
certain
Moslems
liv-
ing
outside
the
frontiers
of
the
Otto¬
man
empire
declare
that
the
removal
of
the Sultan from
Constantinople
would wound
#e
susceptibilities
of
the
faithful,
it
merely
means
the.
persist¬
ence
ef the
great
Panislamic
propa¬
ganda inaugurated
by
Abdul
Hamid
and
continued
by
the
Young
Turks
at
the
kaiser's
instigation.
The
general;
world interest
as
well
as
the interest
of
the
powers
governing
the Mussul¬
man
populations
demand the
removal
cf the
Sultan
aAd
the liberation
of Con¬
stantinople.
To
allow him
to
remain
on
the
Bosporus,
either
as
Sultan
or
Caliph,
would
be to
recognize
a
power
which
even
those
most
particularly
concerned
never
recognized.
"To
lose the
opportunity
of
changing
the Sultan's
place
of
residence would
permit
the continuance
of.
a
permanent
danger
to
the
great
powers
as
well
as
to
the
Christian
population
"It is
necessary
at
the
outset
to
make
a
distinction.
There
will
be
two
different classes
of
states
or
communi¬
ties
under mandate.
There
will
be,
in the
words of the
covenant,
'those
colonies
and
territories
which
bis
countrymen
will
consent,
to
any
treaty
by
which the
nations,
yester¬
day
Russian
allies,
shall
have
appor¬
tioned
Russian
territories
between
i
the
several
border
states,
erected
a
.ew
Poland,
liberated
Finland,
allo-
*
cated Bessarabia
to
Rumania
and
»«cognized
the
independence
of the
.everal tribes of the Baltic prov-
faces?
f
May
Join
Germany
'
are
inhabited
by
peoples
not
yet
able
to
stand
by
themselves under
the
strenuous
conditions
of
fthe
modern
world.' And there
will be 'certain
communities
formerly
belonging
to
the Turkish
Empire
which
have
reached
a
stage
of
development
where
their
existence
as
independent
nations
can
be
provisionally
recognized,
sub¬
ject
to
the
rendering
of
administrative
advice
and assistance
by
a
'nandatary
until
such
time
as
they
are
able to
stand alone.' German
East
Africa is
an
obvious instance
of
the first
class,
Armenia of
the secor.d.-
Thc
Duties
of
u
Mandatary
Nation
"It is
clear that the
civilized
manda¬
tary
power,
whichever
it
be,
in
dealing
with
nr
African
colony
has
two
main
duties, Its
primary
duty
is
toward
the
natives
of
the
colony;
its
secondary
duty
is
toward
the
rest
of
Cue world.
"As
for
the duties
of the
mandatory
power
toward the
outside
world,
they
may
be
summed
up
in
two
words.the
maintenance
of
the.
'open
door.'
There
must
be
complete
equality
of
commer¬
.
.
from
to
defeat
them?
Certainly
France and Great
Britain
cannot
do
thijä.
Even
if
we
sent
new
millions
to
Europe they
would
hardly
arrive
I
in time
to
save
France
from
a
new
invasion.
As
for
the
league
of
na-
tions.
what
power
has
it, outside of
the
power
of
the
nations
which
eon-
stitute
a
real
part
of
it,
and
these
are
Britain,
France
and
ourselves?
Such
briefly,
then,
is
a
conspectus
of
some
of
the
remaining
problems
of
peace;
such is the
unfinished
business
before
the
Paris
conference.
ence.
(Copyright,
1919,
by
The
McClure
Newspaper
Syndicate)
Bo
Red
i
vide
Poland
Instead of
accepting
such
a
situa-
;
tlon,
is
it
not
almost
inevitable
that
the
new
Russia,
the
restored
Russia,
will
join
hand»
with
Germany
in
a
Sew
partition
of Poland,
in
a new
arrangement
«n
the Baltic
lands,
S
which
shall
reproduce
the
situation
bwhkh
has
existed
steadily
since
the
Policies
of
a
great
Russian and
a
great
Prussian,
Peter
and
Freder¬
ick,
brought
Russia
to
the
Baltic
and
excluded
Poland
from
the
open
fea
If Russia
were
condemned always
to he
the
thing
It
is,
it would
be
easy
il«
aettl«
all
th«
question»
now
Ke^
to
tbe
Problem
Armenian
representatives
here
pro.
fess
that
they
have
reason
to be
hope¬
ful that America
will
assume
a
man¬
date.
Meanwhile
the
urgency
of
a
de¬
cision
on
the
Turkish
problem
was ae-
centuatcd
with the arrival of
news
from official
sources
that
the
generals
commanding
three
Turkish
forces in
Asia
Minor.the
first
in
Amsia and
Sivns,
the second
in
Halikersi,
where
they
confront the
Greeks,
and
the
third
'in Konia,
where
they
confront the
Itnlians.refuse
to
obey
orders
ema¬
nating
from
Constantinople,
thus
ren-
dering
immediately
possible
Christian
a
character.
The
Turk
never was more
than
a
temporary
resident,
and
it
is
now
urged
that
the
Sultan's
departure
will result
among
other
benefits
in
cleansing
the
city
of
thousands
of
unproductive
hangers
on
living
at
the
expense
of
the
population
and
constituting
a
serious
obstacle
to
the
peace
and
progress
of the
Orient.
Status of
Sultan
Is
Brought
'
Into
Question
Charles,
a
member
of
the
Turkish
parliament
and
a
noted
authority
on
Moslem
law,
declarea:
"Medina
and
Mecca,
the
chief
centrée of
Mahom-
and
Rumania
in
a
second,
with Bu!
garia
destined,
it would
Keem,
t
join
the
Latin
powers.
But
thi
makes
a
new
Eastern
question
an
gives
Germany
a
chance
to
.selec
partners
from
one
pide
or
the othe
while the
F'aris
Conference,
if
f
R.
Simpson
s
Co.
Inc.
*
^S«i
01"
the
acts
justly,
must
offend
at
least
or
side, and
probably.both,
and
ca
not
enforce
any
decision
it
m¡
reach in
any
case
since its writ
\v
not
run
where it
has
no
armies
go
and it has
no
armies
ttß
flg
143
We.t,42d
St.
¿KSKKS
Levant."
The
thorny problem
of
colonial
man¬
dates
under, the
league
of. nations
is
discussed
by
the Paris
correspondent
of
"The
Manchester
Guardian."
Be
says:
I
of
Anjr Amount
on
LOANS
serious
clashes.
The
danger
<¦
greater
alnea the
cial
rights,
as
well
as
of
religious
rights,
for
all
nations."
Pledget
of
Personal
Property
Rumania
and
Italy
or
conquer
Jugo-
ndependence,
union with
other frac-
lions
of their
own
race
who
are
seek-
rfy>
Established
1827
Broadway,
cor.
67th
St.,
Manhattan
S0i>
Fulton
S\,
Brooklyn
Plik z chomika:
FikuPliku
Inne pliki z tego folderu:
the_sun_the_last_king_of_poland_3oct_1909.pdf
(2285 KB)
the_sun_new_york_19april_1903.pdf
(2718 KB)
the_san_francisco_call_strikes_in_poland_23april_1905.pdf
(3334 KB)
the_lovers_candles_imperial_valley_press_24march_1906.pdf
(1384 KB)
the_jasper_news_why_poland_must_rise_2january_1919.pdf
(520 KB)
Inne foldery tego chomika:
Afery
Agenci
Antoni Macierewicz - sprawy
Centrum Monitoringu Wolności Prasy
Dokumenty Źródłowe IPN
Zgłoś jeśli
naruszono regulamin